Bears Next Target: Bubble in Treasury Bonds
There's a bubble in US Treasury bonds. Here's the explanation:
1. The bailout money is not being lent to consumers, but rather is being used by banks to buy Treasury bonds.
2. We've been seeing Treasury bond prices rise strongly (i.e. falling yield rates), which reflects increased demand for Treasuries. At the same time, though, the fundamentals of the US dollar (the underlying asset the Treasury bond is a derivative of) are deteriorating: the country is carrying more debt while taxes are declining and government spending is increasing, thus signaling even more debt and greater difficulty in repaying it.
3. Consistent with Austrian business cycle theory, bubbles are the result of central bank distortions in the money supply. Peter Schiff recently wrote an excellent article elaborating on this topic as it relates to the Treasury bond market.
As we've seen, bubbles don't last forever -- and they always search for needles. So the question: how will the Treasury bond bubble find its pin, and what happens when it does?
1. According to Ka-Poom Theory (which we previously discussed on TradingGoddess), a black swan event -- an outlier with a disproportional impact -- will be the trigger to causing the Treasury bubble to quickly pop. In recent US history, previous examples of black swan events that have lead to sharp bubble deflations have been (1) 9/11 popping the dot com bubble and (2) the Bear Stearns collapse bringing about the subprime crisis and the collapse of the mortgage bubble.
2. As Treasury bonds are owned primarily by foreign countries, the popping of the bubble will be external to the US economy. In other words, deflating of Treasuries requires debt holders in foreign nations, particularly China and Japan, to sell off.
3. Just as global deleveraging to pay off dollar denominated debts resulted in a sale of foreign currencies to purchase the US dollar, a mass exodus of Treasuries led by foreign holders will result in Treasury bonds being sold and exchanged for foreign currencies ( Iceland and Argentina serve as historical examples of this concept, as they were environments in which bubbles government debt were owned pre-dominantly by foreigners). And given that China and Japan are primary Treasury bond holders, an appreciation in those currencies as that money is brought home seems natural.
So when will it happen?
Impossible to predict, in my opinion. As a market bear by nature, I think playing this from the short side by looking for when momentum in the Treasury bond market turns south represents an opportunity. Currently, the chart for TLT, a 20+ year Treasury bond ETF, looks a bit bullish. and is rallying after bouncing off support in the 111.60 area. Should the market re-test this level with bearish momentum, it may be an opportunity to ride a bear trend as the Treasury bond bubble begins to deflate.
Disclosure: short USDJPY.
Simit Patel
InformedTrades.com
Posted by Simit Patel at 1/15/2009 12:03:00 PM